Open Coil vs. Finned Tubular Electric Heating Elements
Open Coil vs. Finned Tubular Electric Heating Elements
Electric heating elements play a critical role in comfort heating, ventilation, and industrial applications. Choosing the correct element impacts efficiency, safety, longevity, and overall system performance. This guide provides a comparison of open coil and finned tubular heating elements, helping you make an informed decision based on your specific heating requirements.
Open Coil Heating Elements
Open coil heating elements are constructed by winding resistance wire into a coil. Typically, the wire used is either Nichrome-80 or Nichrome-60 alloy. These alloys offer stable electrical properties, excellent oxidation resistance, and the ability to operate at very high temperatures.
Advantages
• Low manufacturing and material cost.
• Fast warm-up and cool-down response which is ideal for forced-air heating systems.
• Minimal surface area provides maximum unrestricted airflow in forced-air designs.
• Compact coil size enables small, space-efficient heater assemblies.
• Inexpensive to repair or replace.
Disadvantages
• Requires consistent, high airflow across coils to prevent overheating.
• Airflow blockages can lead to coil failure.
• Thermal expansion and contraction during heating cycles may reduce lifespan.
• Coils are electrically live and require insulators (typically ceramic) to isolate the element from conductive materials. The coils must also be shielded to prevent electrical shock hazards.
• Insulated supports may crack or break causing an electrical failure. This is a concern in portable heating units that are subjected to excessive movement and abuse.
Best Applications for Open Coil Heating Elements
• Forced-air unit heaters
• Duct heaters with controlled airflow
• Applications requiring rapid thermal response
• Budget-conscious heating systems
Finned Tubular Heating Elements
Finned tubular heating elements begin as open coil heating elements inserted into a metallic sheath (tube). Magnesium oxide (MgO) powder is then packed tightly around the coil for electrical insulation and efficient heat conduction. The tube is swaged to compress the MgO, increasing thermal transfer significantly. Metal fins are then attached to the sheath to maximize the surface area of the element resulting in superior heat distribution.
Advantages
• Exceptionally durable construction suitable for commercial and industrial environments.
• Large, finned surface area delivers high heat-transfer efficiency.
• Lower surface temperature increases lifespan of the element.
• Sheath materials such as stainless steel, steel, or Incoloy can be selected for harsh or corrosive environments.
• Internal coil is fully electrically isolated, improving safety.
• High-limit safety devices can be mounted directly to the element for added protection in hazardous locations.
• Uniform heat distribution due to swaged compression of MgO insulation.
• Lower sheath operating temperatures create more consistent heating performance.
Disadvantages
• More expensive than open coil elements due to material cost and manufacturing complexity.
• Longer warm-up time because fins and sheath must reach temperature before full output is delivered.
Best Applications
• Industrial process heaters
• Commercial unit heaters
• Commercial wall heaters
• Environments requiring durability or corrosion resistance
• Applications needing uniform heat distribution
Conclusion
Both open coil and finned tubular heating elements serve important roles in the electric heating industry. Open coil elements excel in applications that require fast thermal response and cost-efficient heating. Finned tubular elements provide rugged durability, safer operation, and even heat distribution, making them ideal for industrial, commercial, and demanding environments.
Need help selecting the perfect electric heater? You can reach out to us by phone or email — we’re always happy to answer your questions, share our expertise, and help you find the most efficient heating solution for your application.